PetScored is not scoring this product while source-backed regulatory conflict review is open. Product label evidence is captured, but the page does not display a rating, rank, or recommendation.
Not scoredConflict reviewNot verified
Public UI policy
Conflict records show evidence, not ratings.
When product label data is strong but regulatory conflict review is unresolved, PetScored may publish a not-scored page. The page can explain the sources, gaps, and regulatory context, but it cannot show a numeric score, appear in rankings, or imply a clean bill of health.
Verification status
Not scored: blocked by source conflict.
PetScored can show the source record, but it does not show a numeric score while source-backed regulatory conflict review is open.
We show the evidence and the disagreement as they stand. A numeric score returns only if the conflict resolves with source-backed records.
Our captured sources disagree with each other on at least one trust signal. Until review resolves the conflict, the Brand Trust sub-score stays at its seed value rather than scoring contested evidence.
Signal record
conflict
Score basis
Score withheld
Unresolved signals
6
Brand sources
5
What we know
Captured from source records.
Official Victor page supports Hi-Pro Plus identity, 5/15/30/40/50 lb sizes, dry kibble format, all-life-stages positioning, 3815 kcal/kg, 406 kcal/cup, 30/20/3.8/9 GA, full ingredient list, AAFCO all-life-stages statement except growth of large-size dogs, feeding directions, complete general-analysis fields, and Texas-based facility context.
Chewy supports the 50 lb SKU, retailer label fields, GA, calories, and kcal/kg as secondary label support.
Tractor Supply supports a refreshable 40 lb retailer price basis of $66.49 and visible availability context.
FDA advisory confirms recent Mid America/Victor Salmonella recall/outbreak history involving Victor products, including Classic Hi-Pro Plus.
FDA warning-letter and closeout sources confirm a November 22, 2024 Mid America Pet Food warning letter and an August 21, 2025 closeout letter.
Why not scored?
Blocked by conflict review.
Product is not a public scorecard and is not verified.
Conflict-aware Brand Trust review blocks public beta until display/copy policy for recent recall and warning-letter history is accepted.
Recent regulatory history is brand/manufacturer context, not a current product-defect claim.
Named qualified nutritionist, feeding-trial evidence, peer-reviewed research, country-of-origin sourcing, and ownership-stability gates remain unresolved.
Retail price and availability are refreshable and cannot override manufacturer evidence.
PetScored can show label fields to explain what was captured. These fields are not converted into a public score while conflict review is blocking promotion.
Protein
30% / 33.0% DMB
Fat
20% / 22.0% DMB
Fiber
3.8% max
Calories
406 kcal/cup
Adequacy
VICTOR Hi-Pro Plus for Dogs is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for All Life Stages, except for growth of large size dogs (70 lb. or more as an adult).
Source record
Evidence stays visible.
Official Victor product page, Chewy label support, Tractor Supply 40 lb price basis, Mid America ownership/manufacturing context, FDA recall/outbreak advisory, FDA warning letter, and FDA closeout letter are captured. This packet is suitable for conflict-aware draft review only and must not create a public scorecard until copy/policy review accepts the conflict presentation.
